Some people facing deportation can’t safely go back to their home country, but they’ve missed the asylum deadline or are barred from asylum. Withholding of removal and protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT) exist for that situation. The legal standard is higher than asylum, and the protection is narrower.
At Metcalf & Associates, P.C., our attorneys represent clients throughout Chicagoland, including Schaumburg, Hoffman Estates, and the surrounding suburbs, who fear return to another country. If you need a withholding of removal lawyer or a Convention Against Torture lawyer, call 224-328-1900 to schedule a consultation. We will tell you plainly how strong or how difficult your claim looks.
How Does Withholding of Removal Differ From Asylum?
Withholding of removal bars the government from sending you to a specific country where your life or freedom would be threatened, but unlike asylum, it doesn’t lead to a green card or lawful status.
Withholding comes from the Immigration and Nationality Act, 8 U.S.C. § 1231(b)(3). The two forms of relief are requested on the same application, Form I-589, and often in the same hearing. The differences matter:
- Standard of proof: Asylum requires a well-founded fear of persecution, which can be met with a reasonably possible risk. Withholding requires showing it is more likely than not that you would face persecution.
- Deadline: Asylum is subject to a one-year deadline with limited exceptions. Withholding has no filing deadline.
- Discretion: An applicant who qualifies for withholding must be granted it. Asylum is discretionary, so a judge can deny it even when the requirements are met.
- Long-term status: A person granted asylum can apply for permanent residency after a year. Withholding does not provide a path to a green card or lawful immigration status by itself, and it does not provide travel authorization or a right to return to the United States after departing.
If asylum is still available to you, our asylum page covers that route.
Eligibility Requirements for Withholding of Removal
To qualify, you must show it is more likely than not that you would be persecuted in your home country because of race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group.
Those five items are the protected grounds, and the persecution must be based on at least one of them. A particular social group must share a common immutable characteristic, or one so fundamental to identity or conscience that a person should not be required to change it. The group must also be defined with sufficient particularity and be socially distinct within the relevant society. Whether a proposed group meets these requirements depends on the specific facts and applicable immigration law.
If you suffered past persecution in your home country because of one of the five protected grounds, the law presumes that your life or freedom would be threatened again. The government can rebut that presumption by showing that circumstances have fundamentally changed or that you could reasonably relocate to another part of the country to avoid the threat. Without past persecution, you must establish that it is more likely than not that you would face future persecution. If the persecutor is a private individual or group, you must also establish the applicable requirements concerning the government’s inability or unwillingness to control the persecutor. The possibility of safely and reasonably relocating within your home country may also affect your eligibility.
Certain conduct bars withholding entirely:
- Persecuting others: Anyone who took part in persecuting another person on a protected ground is barred.
- Particularly serious crime: An aggravated felony conviction with an aggregate sentence of at least five years is automatically treated as a particularly serious crime for withholding purposes. However, an aggravated felony conviction with a shorter sentence may also be found to constitute a particularly serious crime. Other offenses may qualify depending on the circumstances and applicable law. The definition of aggravated felony is broader than the name suggests.
- Serious nonpolitical crime: A serious nonpolitical crime committed outside the United States before arrival can bar relief.
- Security danger: A person the Attorney General finds to be a danger to U.S. security is barred.
What Counts as Torture Under the Convention Against Torture?
Under 8 C.F.R. § 1208.18, torture involves severe physical or mental pain or suffering that is intentionally inflicted for purposes such as obtaining information, punishment, intimidation, coercion, or discrimination. The harm must be inflicted by, at the instigation of, or with the consent or acquiescence of a public official acting in an official capacity or another person acting in an official capacity. The act must also be directed against someone in the offender’s custody or physical control.
A CAT claim doesn’t require you to tie the harm to a protected ground. You do have to show it is more likely than not that you would be tortured if returned. Immigration judges must consider all relevant evidence, including whether you could relocate to another part of the country where you would not likely face torture. The definition has distinct parts:
- Severe pain or suffering: Mental pain or suffering can qualify, but it must meet specific regulatory requirements. Examples include the intentional infliction or threatened infliction of severe physical pain or suffering, the administration of mind-altering substances or procedures, or the threat of imminent death, when accompanied by the required prolonged mental harm. Harsh conditions alone generally do not meet the legal definition of torture.
- Intentionally inflicted: The harm must be purposeful. Neglect or poor prison conditions without intent generally do not constitute torture.
- Official involvement: The torture must be inflicted by, at the instigation of, or with the consent or acquiescence of a public official or another person acting in an official capacity. Acquiescence requires that an official have actual knowledge of the torture or be willfully blind to a high probability that it will occur, and then breach a legal responsibility to intervene. Mere negligence, recklessness, or failure to investigate is not enough. The official must have had a duty to prevent the torture and failed to intervene despite having the ability to do so.
Two Forms of CAT Relief, and Why the Difference Matters
CAT relief comes in two forms: withholding under the Convention Against Torture, and deferral of removal for people barred from withholding.
Withholding under 8 C.F.R. § 1208.16(c) generally protects eligible individuals from removal to the country where they are more likely than not to be tortured. People subject to certain criminal or security-related bars may be ineligible for CAT withholding but may still qualify for deferral of removal if they meet the CAT standard. Deferral provides more limited and less secure protection because it does not confer lawful immigration status and can be terminated if the individual no longer meets the eligibility requirements or other applicable termination grounds arise. The government may also continue to detain someone who has received deferral of removal, depending on the applicable detention rules.
Either way, the protection is country-specific. The government can still try to remove you to a third country that will accept you.
Evidence That Builds a CAT Claim or Withholding Case
Strong withholding and CAT cases rest on consistent testimony supported by documents, since the applicant carries the burden of proof.
Credible testimony alone can be enough, but corroboration is expected when it is reasonably available. Useful evidence includes:
- Country reports: State Department and human rights organization reports show conditions in your home country and how the government treats people in your position.
- Medical records: Scars, injuries, and psychological evaluations can document past harm.
- Witness statements: Declarations from family members or others who saw what happened. Statements based on third-person information carry less weight than firsthand accounts.
- Personal records: Threats, police reports, membership cards, news coverage, and messages from your home country.
Facing Deportation in Chicagoland: Where These Claims Are Decided
An immigration judge decides most withholding and CAT claims during removal proceedings, and a denial can be appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals.
Most applicants raise these claims defensively in immigration court after the government has started removal proceedings. An asylum officer handles an affirmative asylum application but cannot grant withholding. Someone whose prior removal order has been reinstated and who expresses fear of returning to the designated country generally must first undergo a reasonable fear screening with an asylum officer. If the officer finds a reasonable fear of persecution or torture, the case is referred to an immigration judge for withholding-only proceedings, where the individual can pursue statutory withholding of removal and CAT protection. A negative screening determination may also be reviewed by an immigration judge if the individual requests review.
Outcomes are hard to predict, and many claims fail on the more-likely-than-not standard. Our attorneys review the facts, the evidence, and any criminal history, and tell clients honestly where a claim stands. When a judge denies relief, immigration appeals have short deadlines, so the next step has to be decided quickly.
Questions About Withholding of Removal and CAT Claims
The answers below cover the questions people most often raise when they cannot qualify for asylum.
Can I get a green card if I’m granted withholding of removal?
Not through the withholding grant itself. Withholding doesn’t create lawful status, though you can usually apply for work authorization. A green card would have to come from a separate basis, such as a family relationship.
Do I need to file within a year to apply for withholding?
No. The one-year deadline applies to asylum, not to withholding or CAT protection.
Can a criminal conviction stop me from getting CAT protection?
Certain criminal convictions can prevent someone from receiving withholding of removal under the Convention Against Torture. However, a person who meets the CAT standard may still qualify for deferral of removal even when a criminal conviction makes them ineligible for CAT withholding. Deferral does not provide lawful immigration status, is subject to termination under applicable rules, and does not guarantee release from detention. Employment authorization is subject to separate eligibility requirements.
Talk With a Schaumburg Withholding of Removal Lawyer
Withholding of removal and CAT protection can keep you from being sent to a country where you’d face serious harm, but the standards are demanding, and the deadlines in court are real. Metcalf & Associates, P.C. helps clients from Schaumburg and all across Chicagoland evaluate these claims honestly and prepare evidence for the immigration judge. Call 224-328-1900 to schedule a consultation with our Schaumburg withholding of removal lawyers.
