Criminal Charges and Immigration Consequences in Schaumburg

A plea entered in a suburban Cook County courtroom can take a few minutes. For a non-citizen, the immigration consequences can last for decades. Depending on the offense and the sentence, a conviction can cost a lawful permanent resident a green card, block a pending application, or close the door to citizenship.

Metcalf & Associates, P.C. works with non-citizens who are facing criminal charges or have a past conviction. We serve clients in Schaumburg and throughout Chicagoland. If you want a criminal immigration lawyer to look at your situation before a plea or a filing, call 224-328-1900 to schedule a consultation.

Which Criminal Offenses Create Immigration Problems?

Immigration law identifies specific criminal offenses and categories of conduct that can make a non-citizen deportable or inadmissible. These include crimes involving moral turpitude, aggravated felonies, certain controlled substance offenses, certain domestic violence offenses, and specified firearms offenses. The classification under federal immigration law, rather than simply the label or classification assigned under Illinois law, determines the potential immigration consequences.

The deportable offenses are listed in 8 U.S.C. § 1227. The criminal grounds that make a person inadmissible are in 8 U.S.C. § 1182. The main categories are:

  • Crimes involving moral turpitude: There is no comprehensive statutory list of crimes involving moral turpitude. The classification depends on the elements of the offense and applicable federal immigration law. Such crimes can include certain offenses involving fraud, theft, or intentional serious harm. A single conviction can make a person deportable if the offense was committed within five years after admission to the United States (or within 10 years for certain permanent residents admitted under the specified employment-based adjustment provision) and the offense carries a maximum possible sentence of at least one year. Two or more convictions for crimes involving moral turpitude can also create deportation grounds if they did not arise from a single scheme of criminal misconduct, regardless of when they occurred.
  • Aggravated felonies: This is a defined term under 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(43). It includes offenses such as murder, rape, sexual abuse of a minor, illicit drug trafficking, and certain firearms offenses. It also includes specified theft, burglary, and crimes of violence offenses for which the term of imprisonment is at least one year, as well as certain fraud and deceit offenses involving a loss to the victim exceeding $10,000 and specified money laundering offenses involving funds exceeding $10,000. Whether an offense qualifies depends on the federal statutory definition and the elements of the offense, along with applicable sentencing and loss requirements. An aggravated felony does not have to be classified as a felony under state law; certain misdemeanor convictions can qualify.
  • Drug offenses: Many controlled substance convictions can trigger deportation or inadmissibility, although the precise substance, offense, and applicable federal immigration provision matter. For deportability, federal law provides an exception for a single offense involving possession for personal use of 30 grams or less of marijuana. For inadmissibility, a separate discretionary waiver may be available for certain single offenses involving simple possession of 30 grams or less of marijuana, but it is not an automatic exception.
  • Domestic violence, stalking, and child abuse: Certain convictions for crimes of domestic violence, stalking, and child abuse, neglect, or abandonment can trigger deportation. A violation of a qualifying protection order can also create deportation grounds when a court determines that the individual violated provisions protecting against credible threats of violence, repeated harassment, or bodily injury.
  • Firearms offenses: Certain convictions involving the unlawful purchase, sale, use, ownership, possession, or carrying of a firearm or destructive device can trigger deportation under federal immigration law. The specific weapon, conduct, and applicable federal definition matter, and a lengthy prison sentence is not necessarily required.

How Can a Criminal Conviction Affect Your Green Card, Visa, or Citizenship Application?

A conviction can make a non-citizen deportable, inadmissible, or ineligible for immigration benefits, depending on the person’s status and the offense. Even a charge with no conviction can complicate an application.

Lawful permanent residents face the deportation grounds above. Someone applying for a green card or certain visas may be evaluated under the inadmissibility grounds. Lawful permanent residents returning from international travel may also face questions about past criminal convictions. However, a permanent resident is not automatically treated as an applicant for admission simply because they travel abroad. Specific statutory exceptions determine when a returning permanent resident may be treated as seeking admission, including certain criminal convictions and other circumstances involving their travel or conduct. Depending on the circumstances, immigration officials may refer the person for further inspection or initiate removal proceedings.

Citizenship carries its own test. Applicants must establish good moral character during the applicable statutory period, which is generally five years for most applicants, although shorter periods apply to certain categories of applicants. Some criminal convictions create statutory bars to establishing good moral character, while other offenses and conduct may affect the determination. An aggravated felony conviction entered on or after November 29, 1990, generally creates a permanent statutory bar to establishing good moral character for naturalization purposes. Applying for United States citizenship with an unresolved criminal history can also bring a deportation case to the government’s attention.

Some criminal grounds of inadmissibility may be waived if the individual meets the applicable statutory requirements. Other criminal grounds have no general waiver, although certain forms of relief from removal may still be available depending on the person’s circumstances. Eligibility depends on the specific offense, immigration history, family relationships, and other statutory requirements. Long-term residence in the United States does not automatically prevent removal.

Why the Plea Matters Before Your Criminal Case Ends

A guilty plea is usually the moment that fixes the immigration outcome, so the plea terms need to be reviewed under immigration law before they are accepted. After a conviction is entered, options narrow sharply.

Immigration law defines “conviction” differently from Illinois criminal law. Under federal immigration law, a conviction generally exists when a formal judgment of guilt is entered or, if adjudication is withheld, when a person pleads guilty or is found guilty, admits sufficient facts to warrant a finding of guilt, and the judge orders some form of punishment, penalty, or restraint on liberty. As a result, Illinois court supervision may still qualify as a conviction for immigration purposes, even though it is not treated as a criminal conviction under Illinois law.

The details can be decisive. The sentence imposed can make a significant difference. For certain theft, burglary, and violent offenses, a term of imprisonment of at least one year can trigger the aggravated felony classification. A sentence of 364 days rather than a full year may therefore make a difference, depending on the applicable law and the offense. The specific statute of conviction and its elements also matter. For immigration purposes, a suspended sentence generally still counts toward the applicable term of imprisonment.

Criminal defense attorneys have a constitutional obligation to advise non-citizen clients about the potential immigration consequences of a guilty plea, as the Supreme Court held in Padilla v. Kentucky. When the immigration consequences are clear, attorneys must provide accurate advice. When the consequences are uncertain, they must at least advise clients that the charges may carry adverse immigration consequences. Illinois courts must also provide a statutory warning before accepting a guilty, guilty but mentally ill, or nolo contendere plea to a misdemeanor or felony under 725 ILCS 5/113-8. However, this general warning does not explain how a particular plea, sentence, or conviction may affect an individual’s immigration status.

Working With Your Criminal Defense Attorney in Chicagoland

The immigration analysis and criminal defense strategy should be developed together. Your criminal defense attorney handles the criminal case, while an immigration attorney evaluates how potential charges, plea agreements, and sentences could affect your immigration status. This coordinated approach can help identify potential immigration consequences before you agree to a plea.

A useful immigration review looks at your current status, how you entered, your family ties, your prior record, and the exact statutory language of each charge. That review can show which plea deals or alternative charges avoid a deportable offense, and which ones do not. We can give your criminal defense attorney that written analysis, so negotiations in criminal court are guided by the immigration outcome.

Sometimes the immigration analysis points to a hard result. A plea that avoids immigration trouble may not be available, or the best option may be going to trial. These are decisions to make with both attorneys, before the plea hearing.

Options When Removal Proceedings Have Already Started

A conviction does not always mean removal. Depending on the offense and your history, you may be able to contest the charge, seek relief from removal, or challenge the conviction itself. Outcomes vary, and some cases are long shots.

Certain non-citizens may be subject to mandatory immigration detention under 8 U.S.C. § 1226(c), depending on the specific criminal grounds or other statutory criteria involved. In addition to certain convictions, the statute includes specified inadmissibility grounds that can apply in circumstances involving arrests, charges, or admissions of particular criminal conduct. Individuals subject to mandatory detention generally cannot obtain release through the ordinary immigration bond process, making early legal review particularly important.

Possible avenues include:

  • Contesting the charge: The government must establish that the conviction falls within the applicable ground of removability. Immigration judges generally use the categorical approach, comparing the elements of the criminal statute with the relevant federal immigration definition. When a statute contains alternative elements, the modified categorical approach may apply to determine which statutory offense formed the basis of the conviction. A conviction does not automatically qualify simply because the underlying conduct appears similar to a federally defined offense.
  • Seeking relief: Some people qualify for cancellation of removal, a waiver, or protection based on fear of harm in the home country. An aggravated felony conviction rules out many of these forms of relief.
  • Challenging the conviction: A conviction vacated because of a substantive or procedural legal defect may no longer qualify as a conviction for immigration purposes. For example, a person may be able to challenge a guilty plea based on ineffective assistance of counsel involving immigration advice, depending on the circumstances and applicable post-conviction procedures. However, a conviction vacated solely for rehabilitation, immigration hardship, or other reasons unrelated to a legal defect generally continues to count for immigration purposes. The availability of post-conviction relief depends on the applicable law, procedural deadlines, and the facts of the case.

Our broader deportation defense page covers how removal cases proceed in immigration court.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a misdemeanor lead to deportation?

Yes. A misdemeanor can trigger immigration consequences if it falls within a deportable or inadmissible criminal category under federal immigration law. Depending on the offense, this may include certain crimes involving moral turpitude, controlled substance offenses, domestic violence offenses, or even offenses classified as aggravated felonies. For example, certain theft misdemeanors can qualify as aggravated felonies if the offense meets the applicable federal definition and the term of imprisonment is at least one year.

Does an arrest without a conviction affect my immigration status?

An arrest alone does not generally constitute a conviction under federal immigration law. However, it can still affect an immigration application or proceeding. Immigration officials may ask about arrests and the circumstances surrounding them, and the underlying conduct may be relevant to certain discretionary immigration decisions or good moral character determinations. An arrest or dismissed charge does not automatically establish that a person committed the alleged offense, but it is important to understand how the incident may affect an application before filing.

I already pleaded guilty years ago. Is it too late to get help?

Not necessarily. Whether an old conviction creates an immigration problem depends on the offense, the sentence, the date of the conviction, and your current immigration status. Some individuals may have grounds to challenge a conviction, contest removal proceedings, or seek available immigration relief. However, legal deadlines and restrictions on challenging older convictions may apply. Reviewing the criminal court records and immigration history is an important first step in determining what options may be available.

Talk With a Schaumburg Crimmigration Lawyer Before the Next Court Date

If you are facing criminal charges, or a past conviction is holding up a green card or citizenship application, the earlier we review the record, the more options you are likely to have. Metcalf & Associates, P.C. serves Schaumburg, Hoffman Estates, and communities throughout Chicagoland. Call 224-328-1900 to schedule a consultation. We will tell you plainly what the law allows and where a case is a long shot.